Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

NCH, Florida Blue still at odds over contract with viability of care network at stake

Naples-based NCH may be considered out of network at the end of September if the two parties can’t come to an agreement.

Naples-based NCH Healthcare System, an in-network provider for Florida Blue for many years, may be considered out of network at the end of September if the parties can’t come to an agreement.

NCH maintains that it can’t provide its services at the current level of Florida Blue’s reimbursement, and Florida Blue believes NCH is asking for an unreasonable payment rate.

The hospital held a town hall-style meeting this week, where NCH president and CEO Paul Hiltz described the problem and what he hopes will happen.

“We hope, and we think this can be resolved, before the end of this month, if they just come to a fair rate,” said Hiltz.

Dr. Betsy Brothers is OB-GYN department chair at the hospital.

“We had a record number of (labor) deliveries in August, the highest number since pre-COVID. And with the commitment of the hospital to taking care of women and children, despite the poor compensation, we have to certainly acknowledge our community’s hospital as being a good steward for all the women and children here in Naples and in Collier County,” Dr. Brothers said.

Chief operations officer Jon Kling says in his 22 years at NCH, the health system has never been this close to going out of network with an insurance provider. He says that costs have risen, and reimbursement has not kept up.

“The pandemic and the current inflationary impacts in our community, in our nation have exacerbated this to the point where we can no longer provide the services and continue to lose the dollars we are for the services we provide,” said Kling.

Phillip Lee is Florida Blue’s market resident for the West Region, which includes Southwest Florida. He says there are about 40,000 Florida Blue members in the Naples community. He adds that what the hospital is asking for is not tenable.

“NCH has continued to request rate increases and demands that are absolutely unreasonable,” said Lee.

Yet he, like the NCH staffers, claim to be looking out for NCH patients.

“We’re committed to working with NCH to arrive at and provide some level of resolution. But we are really advocating on behalf of the people we are here to serve.”

The contract expires on Sept. 30, at which point NCH Health System will be out of network for Florida Blue members.

Copyright 2024 WGCU

Cary Barbor is the local host of All Things Considered and a reporter for WGCU. She was a producer for Martha Stewart Radio on Sirius XM, where she hosted a live interview show with authors of new books called Books and Authors. She was a producer for The Leonard Lopate Show, a live, daily show that covered arts, culture, politics, and food on New York City’s public radio station WNYC. She also worked as a producer on Studio 360, a weekly culture magazine; and The Sunday Long Read, a show that features in-depth conversations with journalists and other writers. She has filed stories for The Pulse and Here & Now. In addition to radio, she has a career writing for magazines, including Salon, Teen Vogue, New York, Health, and More. She has published short stories and personal essays and is always working on a novel. She was a Knight Journalism Fellow, where she studied health reporting at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta and followed epidemiologists around Kenya and Alaska. She has a B.A. in English from Lafayette College and an M.A. in Literature from the University of Massachusetts.