Miracle Of Hemophilia Drugs Comes At A Steep Price

Mar 5, 2018
Originally published on March 7, 2018 1:47 pm

When Landon Morris was diagnosed with hemophilia shortly after birth, his mother, Jessica Morris, was devastated. "It was like having your dreams — all the dreams you imagined for your child — just kind of disappear," she recalled.

Hemophilia, a rare bleeding disorder caused by a gene mutation that prevents blood from clotting properly, is typically passed from mother to son. Morris' grandfather had it, and she remembered hearing how painful it was. "It was almost like he was bubble-wrapped," she said. "He was coddled, because his mom didn't want him to get hurt."

But Landon's life turned out to be much different than she expected.

"He's wild. He's probably sometimes the roughest of them all," she said, as she watched the 6-year-old race around a park in Yuba City, Calif., where the family lives. "He leads a totally normal life. He plays T-ball. He'll start soccer in the fall. He runs and jumps and wrestles with his brothers."

His active approach to life is made possible by his medication — the kind that wasn't available in his grandfather's day. For the Morris family, this type of drug — broadly known as clotting factor — is a miracle, helping Landon's blood clot normally. And its cost is almost entirely covered by his father's federal employee health plan.

But for the health care system, such drugs are enormously expensive, among the priciest in the nation. Medications to treat hemophilia cost an average of more than $270,000 annually per patient, according to a 2015 Express Scripts report. If complications arise, that yearly price tag can soar above $1 million. The U.S. hemophilia drug market, which serves about 20,000 patients, is worth $4.6 billion a year, according to the investment research firm AllianceBernstein.

Examining the stubbornly high cost of these medications opens a window into why some prescription drugs the United States — especially those for rare diseases — have stratospheric prices. The short answer: Competition doesn't do its traditional job of tamping down costs.

Vying For Patients

The market for hemophilia medicines in the United States is flooded with 28 different drugs, with another 21 drugs in development. Blood factor drugs are biological products — in this case, a protein — and there are no cheaper copies, called biosimilars, available. Not only do prices rise steadily as each new product comes on the market, demand is growing — and pushing costs upward — as more and more clotting factor is used to prevent bleeding episodes, not just to treat them.

Yet competition has not brought prices down in the way someone "operating at the level of undergrad Econ 101 would expect," said Jerry Avorn, a professor at Harvard Medical School who studies prescription drug costs.

The problem is that companies have no incentive to lower prices. Patients generally don't push back because insurers pay the bulk of the cost. And insurers tend not to object because the market for the drugs — expensive as they are — is small and the patients are especially vulnerable.

For drug companies, Avorn said, "it's a magical formula: Lifesaving drug, child at risk of bleeding to death — it kind of casts anybody who looks at costs into the role of some evil Scrooge-like person."

"The insurers don't want to end up on the front page of the newspaper saying Little Timmy bled to death because his drug wasn't covered," he said.

Also, because prices are high across the hemophilia market, no drug company wants to be the one to blink first. "They don't want to get a price war started and end up at a super low price point," said Edmund Pezalla, a consultant to pharmaceutical companies and former executive at Aetna.

So, these drugmakers compete not on price but clinical benefits — such as how long the drugs' effects last — and through intensive marketing. The pool of potential customers is so valuable that companies often vie directly for individual patients.

Manufacturers, as well as specialty pharmacies that sell the drugs, hire patients and parents as recruiters and advisers, hold dinners and holiday parties, offer scholarships to patients and even run summer camps for children with the disease. The Morris family regularly receives such invitations.

Dr. Jonathan Ducore, a pediatric hematologist-oncologist at the UC Davis Hemophilia Treatment Center in Sacramento, said some of his patients are persuaded by drug company presentations to switch medications. "But the real differences between the drugs are limited," he said.

Ducore tells his patients if he thinks they are being misled by drugmakers about what a product will do. "But even though the tactics may seem a little smarmy, if it's the patient's choice, you have to go with it," said Ducore, who has been Landon's doctor since the boy was born.

The first clotting factor products, which came onto the market in the mid-1960s, were derived from human blood plasma, with thousands of donations combined to create one batch. This proved disastrous in the 1980s, when donors unwittingly spread HIV into the blood supply. An estimated 4,000 people with hemophilia — about 40 percent of the patient population in the U.S. — died from AIDS as a result.

In the 1990s, manufacturers introduced a product that did not carry the disease risk of plasma-based drugs — made by cloning human clotting proteins in animal cells. Companies charged a premium for this ever-more-popular "recombinant factor."

Recombinant factor is difficult and delicate to make, said Steve Garger, a development scientist at Bayer, which produces two popular factor products at its Berkeley, Calif., plant — including Landon Morris' drug, Kogenate.

Inside a concrete building on the campus, kidney cells from baby hamsters are grown in stainless-steel vessels called bioreactors, and the clotting factor they produce is then purified in steel tanks kept in cold rooms. Working at full capacity, this factory produces less than a pound of clotting factor each year — but when diluted with other ingredients, it's enough to treat thousands of patients in 80 countries.

The investment in manufacturing and marketing is only part of the reason for the high cost of the drugs, said Kevin O'Leary, vice president of pricing and contracting at Bayer. Bayer does not simply add up the costs, slap on a profit margin and come up with the price, O'Leary explained.

Instead, he said, the company begins by talking to insurers, doctors and patients to get a sense of what value its products bring to the market, especially compared to drugs already available. Bayer then sets a price based on both its investment and the product's perceived worth. In the end, he said, "we're charging a price that's competitive with the other factor products on the market."

Bayer's annual sales from its hemophilia drugs were 1.17 billion euros in 2016, the equivalent of $1.45 billion in the U.S.

Pushing Back On Costs

In Europe, hemophilia drugs cost less than half what they cost in the U.S. That's because payers — usually governments — request bids and pick products based on cost and quality.

Without pushback from insurers in the U.S., "the price of any drug in the U.S. is whatever the market will bear as seen by the manufacturer," said Avorn of Harvard.

Recently, a few insurance companies have quietly started to push back on costs. Bayer's O'Leary said several insurers have approached the company and demanded rebates in exchange for offering the drug to their customers. O'Leary would not discuss the details because he said the contracts are confidential.

State Medicaid programs, which provide health insurance to low-income Americans and cover about half of hemophilia patients, already receive significant rebates from hemophilia drug manufacturers.

Michelle Rice, a senior vice president at the National Hemophilia Foundation, said she has been working with several insurers to help them manage costs safely. "We understand the need to control costs, but they can't impede access to the product a patient needs," she said.

It is not yet clear whether such efforts will work, let alone spread.

Sitting at a picnic bench at a park, Jessica Morris pages through Landon's insurance documents. Over the past year, his care cost over $120,000. She wonders sometimes what would happen if they lost their coverage.

"How much would you be willing to pay to have your child lead a normal life?" she said. "I don't think that there's anything we wouldn't pay or sacrifice for him."

It's a problem she prays they'll never have to face.


Kaiser Health News is a nonprofit news service covering health issues. It is an editorially independent program of the Kaiser Family Foundation that is not affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.

Copyright 2018 Kaiser Health News. To see more, visit Kaiser Health News.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Drugs to treat hemophilia are among the most expensive on the market. They can cost more than a million dollars a year for a single patient. People with hemophilia can bleed to death if they don't get their medicine. So why do the drugs cost so much? Jenny Gold has this story from Northern California.

JENNY GOLD: Landon Morris was diagnosed with hemophilia right after he was born. His mother, Jessica Morris, was devastated.

JESSICA MORRIS: It was like having your dreams - all the dreams you imagined for your child - just kind of disappear.

GOLD: Landon, who's 6 now, is the third of Morris' four boys. He's the only one with hemophilia, a gene mutation that prevents blood from clotting properly. Jessica Morris knew how painful hemophilia could be. Her grandfather had it, and she had decided to name Landon after him even before he was diagnosed. Life for Grandpa Landon wasn't easy.

J. MORRIS: It was almost like he was bubble-wrapped. He was coddled because his mom didn't want him to get hurt.

GOLD: Hemophilia is usually passed from mother to son. Jessica worried little Landon was destined to relive her grandfather's struggles. Life didn't turn out quite like she'd expected.

LANDON MORRIS: Ah, whee (ph).

J. MORRIS: He's wild. He's probably sometimes the roughest of them all.

GOLD: At a park near their house in Yuba City, Landon and his brothers Luke, Logan and Levi attack the climbing structure.

J. MORRIS: Landon, don't do that, please - Landon James.

He leads a totally normal life. He plays T-ball. He'll start soccer in the fall, runs and jumps and wrestles with his brothers.

GOLD: Without Landon's medication - the kind that wasn't available to his grandfather - this kind of rough and tumble play could be deadly. Three times a week, Jessica and her husband, Shane, inject a clotting protein into Landon's vein. It's called factor VIII.

J. MORRIS: So then you inject the saline solution, and you mix it around.

GOLD: The hardest part is getting Landon to sit still.

J. MORRIS: Landon, please stop.

GOLD: For the Morrises, this drug is a miracle. But for the health care system, it's a huge expense. On average, patients with severe hemophilia cost more than $270,000 a year, so it's no surprise perhaps that lots of drug companies want in. There are more than two dozen factor products on the U.S. market for just 20,000 hemophilia patients. Landon's father, Shane Morris, says that makes his family a hot commodity.

SHANE MORRIS: The drug companies almost in a way really want to cater to you to get you on their product.

GOLD: And the companies aren't shy about reaching out.

S. MORRIS: Basically, you know, the companies put on these dinners or these gatherings - right? - to kind of promote their product.

J. MORRIS: We just went to a dinner almost two weeks ago for a new drug.

S. MORRIS: It's convincing in some respects. But, you know, really, when it gets down to the bottom line, they all do the same thing.

GOLD: Companies embed themselves in the tightknit hemophilia community. They employ patients and their family members. They hold potlucks and holiday parties. But one thing they don't seem to compete on is price. All of the drug prices from all of the companies remain stubbornly high. I wanted to understand why, so I called Bayer Pharmaceuticals, which makes the drug that Landon takes. Bayer's Steve Garger gave me a tour of their factory in Berkeley, Calif.

STEVE GARGER: So this is the first part of the factor VIII manufacturing process.

GOLD: He points out the steel tanks of baby hamster kidney cells, engineered to produce human clotting protein.

GARGER: A single vial of cell bank is thawed, and the cells are expanded.

GOLD: This is very delicate stuff. We had to put on three layers of sterile suits just to come in. It's expensive to make and to develop and market, says Kevin O'Leary, who's in charge of Bayer's pricing and contracting. So if you add up all those expenses plus some extra for profit, is that why these drugs cost so much? O'Leary says no.

KEVIN O'LEARY: You can't add up the cold storage plus this plus that plus that and come up with a price for the product because that's not the way we price it.

GOLD: So how does Bayer price it? O'Leary says it's based on the value they think their innovation brings to the market, especially compared to other drugs already out there. But with so many similar products, shouldn't costs go down - nope. O'Leary says that's because insurance companies have so far been willing to cover all the options regardless of cost.

O'LEARY: So lowering the price is not something that would result in greater market share.

GOLD: In other words, since insurers pay for the drugs no matter the price, companies like Bayer really have no incentive to lower them. Unlike what you may have learned in Economics 101, competition doesn't always lower prices.

JERRY AVORN: The price of any drug in the U.S. is whatever the market will bear, as seen by the manufacturer.

GOLD: That's Jerry Avorn, a professor at Harvard Medical School who studies costs. He says for the most part, insurers haven't been willing to push back on the cost of hemophilia drugs.

AVORN: The insurers don't want to end up on the front page of the newspaper saying, little Timmy bled to death because his drug wasn't covered.

GOLD: And since hemophilia is so rare, no one insurance company has enough patients who take the drugs to risk the fallout. Here's Avorn again.

AVORN: It's a magical formula - you know, a lifesaving drug, child at risk of bleeding to death. You know, it kind of casts anybody who looks at costs into the role of some evil Scrooge-like person. But we got to get over that.

GOLD: Avorn says these questions should matter to all of us since insurers pass those costs along in the form of higher premiums for everyone.

J. MORRIS: You got to go play.

GOLD: Back in Yuba City, Jessica Morris watches as Landon plays in the park with his brothers.

J. MORRIS: How much would you be willing to pay to have your child lead a normal life?

GOLD: She knows they're lucky to have insurance that covers almost all of Landon's $120,000 in care each year, but she sometimes wonders what would happen if they lost their coverage.

J. MORRIS: I don't think that there's anything I wouldn't pay so that he could run around the park and ride his bikes and tackle his brothers. I don't think that there's anything we wouldn't pay or sacrifice for him.

GOLD: It's a problem she prays they'll never have to face. I'm Jenny Gold in Yuba City, Calif.

SHAPIRO: And Jenny Gold is with Kaiser Health News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.