Emergency Medical Responders Confront Racial Bias

Jan 3, 2019
Originally published on January 4, 2019 2:37 pm

A recent study out of Oregon suggests emergency medical responders — EMTs and paramedics — may be treating minority patients differently from the way they treat white patients.

Specifically, the scientists found that black patients in their study were 40 percent less likely to get pain medication than their white peers.

Jamie Kennel, head of emergency medical services programs at Oregon Health and Science University and the Oregon Institute of Technology, led the research, which was presented in December at the Institute for Healthcare Improvement Scientific Symposium in Orlando, Fla.

The researchers received a grant to produce the internal report for the Oregon Emergency Medical Services department and the Oregon Office of Rural Health.

Outright discrimination by paramedics is rare, the researchers say, and illegal; in this case unconscious bias may be at work.

A few years ago, Leslie Gregory was one of a very few black female emergency medical technicians working in Lenawee County, Mich. She says the study's findings ring true to what she has seen.

She remembers one particular call — the patient was down and in pain. As the EMTs arrived at the scene, Gregory could see the patient was black. And that's when one of her colleagues groaned.

"I think it was something like: 'Oh, my God. Here we go again,' " Gregory says. She worried — then, as now — that because the patient was black, her colleague assumed he was acting out to get pain medication.

Leslie Gregory, a Portland physician assistant, asks, "How can a person of color not disrespect a system that is constantly studying and talking about these disparities, but does nothing to fix it?" She wants the CDC to declare racism a threat to public health.
Kristian Foden-Vencil/Oregon Public Broadcasting

"I am absolutely sure this was unconscious," adds Gregory, who now lives and works in Portland, Ore. "At the time, I remember, it increased my stress as we rode up on this person. Because I thought, 'Now am I going to have to fight my colleague for more pain medication, should that arise?' "

Unconscious bias can be subtle — but, as this new report shows, it may be one of factors behind race-linked health disparities seen across the U.S.

The study looked at 104,000 medical charts of ambulance patients between 2015 and 2017. It found minority patients were less likely to receive morphine and other pain medication compared with white patients — regardless of socioeconomic factors, such as health insurance status.

Gregory is now a physician assistant, and one of her current patients, a black veteran, has cyclic vomiting syndrome. That means he periodically experiences bouts of vomiting he can't stop without hydromorphone, a potent opioid.

If the man doesn't get the medicine when he needs it, he could rupture his esophagus and die, Gregory says.

So he doesn't call the ambulance anymore. Instead, he goes straight to a hospital emergency department for help. But, Gregory says, the same thing keeps happening — the health professionals in the ER won't prescribe him the medicine he needs.

"I took his entire medical record and faxed it over to the emergency department director of a local hospital system, in anticipation of this very problem," Gregory says. "And still, when he presented, it was the same exact thing."

During a shift change at American Medical Response headquarters in Portland, I discuss the problem with EMTs and paramedics who are getting their rigs ready for the next shift.

Paramedic Jason Dahlke says he can see how unconscious bias could slip into an emergency responder's decisions and taint health care. He has worked hard to be aware of it, in hopes of preventing those disparities in care.
Kristian Foden-Vencil/Oregon Public Broadcasting

Jennifer Sanders, who has been a paramedic for 30 years, tells me she has heard about the new study. She is adamant that her work is not affected by race.

"I've never treated anybody different — regardless," says Sanders.

Most of the emergency responders I speak with, including Jason Dahlke, say race doesn't affect the treatment they give. But Dahlke also says he and some of his co-workers are thinking deeply about unconscious bias.

"Historically it's the way this country has been," Dahlke says. "In the beginning we had slavery and Jim Crow and redlining — and all of that stuff you can get lost in on a large, macro scale. Yeah. It's there."

Ask Dahlke where he thinks unconscious bias could slip in, and he talks about a patient he just treated.

The man was black and around 60 years old. Dahlke is white and in his 30s. The patient has diabetes and called 911 from home, complaining of extreme pain in his hands and feet.

When Dahlke arrived at the patient's house, he followed standard procedure and gave the patient a blood glucose test. The results showed that the man's blood sugar level was low.

"So it's my decision to treat this blood sugar first. Make sure that number comes up," Dahlke says.

He gave the patient glucose — but no pain medicine.

Dahlke says he did not address the man's pain in this case because by the time he had stabilized the patient they had arrived at the hospital — where it was the responsibility of the emergency department staff to take over.

"When people are acutely sick or injured, pain medication is important," Dahlke says. "But it's not the first thing we're going to worry about. We're going to worry about life threats. You're not necessarily going to die from pain, and we're going to do what satisfies the need in the moment to get you into the ambulance and to the hospital and to a higher level of care."

Dahlke says he is not sure whether, if the patient had been white, he would have administered pain medicine, though he doesn't think so.

"Is it something that I think about when I come across a patient that does not look like me? I don't know that it changes my treatment," he says.

Asked whether treatment disparities might sometimes be a result of white people being more likely to ask for more medications, Dahlke smiles.

"I wonder that — if, in this study, if we're talking about people of color being denied or not given narcotic medicines as much as white people, then maybe we're overtreating white people with narcotic medicines."

Research has also found African-Americans more likely to be deeply distrustful of the medical community, and that might play a role in diminished care, too. Such distrust is understandable and goes back generations, says Gregory.

"How can a person of color not disrespect a system that is constantly studying and talking about these disparities, but does nothing to fix it?" she asks.

Gregory wrote an open letter to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in 2015, asking it to declare racism a threat to public health.

Past declarations of crisis — such as those focusing attention on problems such as smoking or HIV — have had significant results, Gregory notes.

But the CDC told Gregory, in its emailed response, that while it supports government policies to combat racial discrimination and acknowledges the role of racism in health disparities, "racism and racial discrimination in health is a societal issue as well as a public health one, and one that requires a broad-based societal strategy to effectively dismantle racism and its negative impacts in the U.S."

Kennel says false stereotypes about race-based differences in physiology that date to slavery also play a role in health care disparities. For example, despite a lack of any supporting science, some medical professionals still think the blood of African-Americans coagulates faster, Kennel says, citing a recent study of medical students at the University of Virginia.

Another question in the survey asked the students whether they thought African-Americans have fewer pain receptors than whites. "An uncomfortably large percentage of medical students said, 'Yes, that's true,' " says Kennel.

On top of that, he says, EMTs and paramedics often work in time-pressured situations, where they are limited to ambiguous clinical information and scarce resources. "In these situations, providers are much more likely to default to making decisions [based] on stereotypes," he says.

Disparities in health care are well-documented. Whites tend to get better care and experience better outcomes, whether they're in a doctor's office or the ER. But before Kennel's study, nobody knew whether the same was true in the back of an ambulance.

And they nearly didn't get to know, because the research required ambulance companies to release highly sensitive data.

"We were prepared to maybe not look that great," explains Robert McDonald, the operations manager at American Medical Response in Portland. AMR is one of the nation's largest ambulance organizations, and it shared its data from more than 100,000 charts with Kennel.

Some people chalk up the disparities he found to differences in demography and health insurance status, but Kennel says he controlled for those variables.

So now that AMR knows about disparities in its care, what can the company do?

"My feeling is we're probably going to put some education and training out to our folks in the field," McDonald says.

In addition, he says, AMR is going to hire more people of color.

"We want to see more ethnicities represented in EMS — which has historically been a white, male-dominated workforce," McDonald says.

AMR's policies must change, too, he adds. The company has purchased software that will enable patients to read medical permission forms in any of 17 different languages. And the firm is planning an outreach effort to communities of color to explain the role of EMS workers.

This story is part of NPR's reporting partnership with Oregon Public Broadcasting and Kaiser Health News, a nonprofit news service of the Kaiser Family Foundation. KHN is not affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.

Copyright 2019 Oregon Public Broadcasting. To see more, visit Oregon Public Broadcasting.

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

There's a recent study out of Oregon that shows that race comes into play, even when it means administering lifesaving care. Specifically, this study shows black patients are 40 percent less likely to get pain medication than white people. Kristian Foden-Vencil of Oregon Public Broadcasting reports.

KRISTIAN FODEN-VENCIL, BYLINE: Differences in how races are treated by doctors in the ER are well-documented. Whites tend to get better care and have healthier outcomes. But until this study, it was unclear if the same was happening in an emergency in the back of an ambulance. Leslie Gregory always wondered. Now a physician assistant, Gregory got her start as one of a very few black, female EMTs. She remembers one call. The patient was down and in pain. Driving up, she could see he was black. Then one of her colleagues groaned.

LESLIE GREGORY: It was something like, oh, God. Here we go again.

FODEN-VENCIL: She worried her colleague thought that because he was black, he was acting out to get pain meds.

GREGORY: At the time, I remember it increased my stress as we rode up on this person because I thought, now, am I going to have to fight my colleague for more pain medication, should that arise?

FODEN-VENCIL: A group of researchers at Oregon Health and Science University decided to try to see if there was a difference in the way patients were treated on emergency calls. They looked at 100,000 medical charts of ambulance patients over three years. Black patients were less likely to receive pain medications compared to white patients, regardless of socio-economic factors like health insurance.

(SOUNDBITE OF BANG)

FODEN-VENCIL: At the end of a recent shift at American Medical Response in Portland, a row of ambulances files into the garage. Many emergency responders here bristle at the idea race plays a role in care. Jennifer Sanders has been a paramedic for 30 years.

JENNIFER SANDERS: I've never treated anybody different regardless.

FODEN-VENCIL: The very idea is distasteful, says paramedic Jason Dahlke.

JASON DAHLKE: No one I work with will explicitly and intentionally discriminate against somebody. It's not what we do. It's not the business that we're in.

FODEN-VENCIL: But Dahlke is willing to entertain the idea unconscious bias is at work in his field.

DAHLKE: Historically, it's the way this country has been. In the beginning, we had slavery and then Jim Crow and then redlining and all of this stuff that you can get lost in in, like, a large, macro scale. So yeah, it's there.

FODEN-VENCIL: So this study is given import. He mentions an older black patient he just treated. He was diabetic and complaining of extreme pain. Dahlke gave him glucose for low blood sugar but no pain meds. He says that's because by the time he'd stabilized his blood sugar, they'd reached the hospital. And would he have done anything differently if the patient had been white?

DAHLKE: Consciously, absolutely not. Unconsciously, that's what studies are saying.

FODEN-VENCIL: Dahlke thinks another issue at play may be that white patients are more comfortable asking for medications than patients of color. Former EMT Leslie Gregory agrees. She says after years of discrimination, many African-Americans have their own biases about the medical system. They just don't trust it.

GREGORY: How can a person of color not disrespect a system that is constantly studying and talking about these disparities but does nothing to fix it?

FODEN-VENCIL: The author of this new ambulance study, Jamie Kennel, says another reason disparities loom so large may be that EMTs work in a stressful and time-pressured environment.

JAMIE KENNEL: In these situations, providers are much more likely to default to making decisions based on stereotypes.

FODEN-VENCIL: So now ambulance agencies know unconscious bias may be at work. What are they doing about it? Robert McDonald with American Medical Response says he's looking at new training and a change in hiring practices.

ROBERT MCDONALD: We want to see more ethnicities represented in EMS that has historically been a white, male-dominated workforce.

FODEN-VENCIL: The first step, though, is for emergency workers to just be aware of the role bias may play in care. For NPR News, I'm Kristian Foden-Vencil in Portland.

(SOUNDBITE OF OLDTWIG'S "DUNES")

MARTIN: This story is part of a partnership with NPR, Oregon Public Broadcasting and Kaiser Health News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.