It's time to screen all kids for anxiety, a physicians' task force recommends
In light of the growing kids' mental health crisis, the group says it's crucial to identify kids who are struggling. The advice doesn't call for suicide screening, which many experts think is needed.
An influential panel of experts says all kids ages eight to 18 should be screened regularly for anxiety. This draft recommendation by the United States Preventive Task Force comes at a time when mental health problems among kids have escalated and are overwhelming the health system.
The task force also recommends that kids 12 and older continue to be screened for depression, a recommendation that's been in place since 2016.
The screenings are usually done by primary care physicians using standardized questionnaires that parents and/or kids answer, depending on their age.
"We were already seeing rising rates of anxiety, depression and also suicide behaviors and suicide in our young people," says Martha Kubik, a professor of nursing at George Mason University and a member of the task force.
The goal of the screenings, she says, is to help doctors and other providers identify at-risk kids early on in the trajectory of their illness so that they can be treated before symptoms escalate.
Child and adolescent mental health experts welcome the recommendations.
It has increasingly become clear that most mental illnesses manifest in childhood and adolescence, says Dr. Jennifer Havens, the chair of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at NYU's Grossman School of Medicine.
But anxiety disorder, one of the most common mental illnesses among children, can go undetected for a long time.
"It can be quiet. Kids who are anxious are often very self-conscious and aren't going to share this with their families or their physicians, necessarily. So screening is a very, very good idea."
Most cases of anxiety in children can be treated with psychotherapy, she adds. Only kids with severe anxiety need medication. That's why, she says, the earlier a child is diagnosed, the easier it is to treat.
Kids with anxiety disorders are at higher risk of anxiety disorders and depression in adulthood, along with related risks like substance abuse, the recommendation notes.
Pediatricians have long recognized the need for screening, says Dr. Sandy Chung, president-elect of the American Academy of Pediatrics, because they've seen an increasing number of their patients struggle with a range of mental health symptoms for years. Those grew to alarming numbers during the pandemic.
"We are truly in a crisis situation with mental health," she adds.
In the fall of 2021, the AAP along with the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and the Children's Hospital Association issued a statement calling children's mental health a national emergency.
The AAP had already recommended screening teens for emotional and behavioral problems like anxiety and depression, and many pediatricians are already screening their patients for anxiety and depression, adds Chung.
"We appreciate the task force making the recommendation, but in reality, many pediatricians are already doing the work [already]," she says.
Many of those pediatricians are connected to psychiatrists and psychologists by telephone through what are called mental health access programs, adds Chung, who helped start the Virginia Mental Health Access program.
Some pediatric clinics that do mental health screens are able to provide follow up care through in-house providers. For example, Montefiore Medical Center, which screens about 86,000 children annually for emotional and behavioral problems.
"In our primary care practices, where children go to see their pediatrician, we already screen for pediatric anxiety, depression and also attention problems beginning actually when children are four years of age," says Miguelina German, a pediatric psychologist at the center, which has behavioral health providers like herself integrated into the practice.
Anyone who screens positive is referred to German or one of her behavioral health colleagues.
And the younger a child is when they screen positive for a mental health problem, the easier it is for her and her colleagues to treat them, she adds, because mental health problems worsen with age, if left untreated.
"If I have a 15 year old who's anxious, the odds that she's also going to be depressed are very high," says German. "But once upon a time that 15 year old was 10 years old, and let's say when she was 10 years old, she had some social anxiety. She was having some trouble making friends."
Also, if providers treat children's problems when they are younger when symptoms start emerging, she says, it often requires fewer sessions than treating a more complex problem in an older child.
That's why she hopes this model of integrating mental health care into pediatrician's offices along with universal screening for mental health symptoms will become the standard of care across the country.
The panel also looked into the evidence behind screening for suicide, and found insufficient evidence to support the idea.
But that decision troubles Dr. Christine Yu Moutier, the chief medical officer of the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention.
"It is of great concern to us that the the task force is not looking at the more recent data that actually shows that screening for suicide risk can be done effectively safely," says Moutier.
There are more than six recent studies that show that asking kids if they have had thoughts of hurting themselves can really help open up a safe space for them to talk about their distress, she adds.
"We know that many youth who are thinking of suicide do not tell anyone," she says. "And so we do need to screen."
The AAP and AFSP recently released a blueprint for preventing youth suicide, which recommends screening adolescents for suicide.
The draft recommendations are open for public comments until May 9, says Kubik, and the final recommendations will likely be released by the end of 2022.
Moutier hopes the final advice will include a recommendation to screen kids for suicide as well.
Copyright 2022 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.