Alzheimer's Trial Struggles To Find Participants
When you’ve been diagnosed with an incurable disease, there’s a huge incentive to sign up for a drug trial. But what if you’re healthy? What’s the incentive?
That’s the challenge facing researchers in a groundbreaking double-blind trial of an experimental drug meant to ward off Alzheimer’s disease. It is the Anti-Amyloid Treatment and Asymptomatic Alzheimer’s Disease trial, better known as “A4.”
Thousands more volunteers – including Floridians - are needed in the test population: people ages 65 to 85 who appear to have normal memories. They can be tough to recruit, said Keith Fargo, director of scientific programs and outreach for the Alzheimer’s Association.
”They’re looking for people who are very high-risk for Alzheimer’s disease but who don’t yet have any symptoms, such as memory problems or difficulty thinking,” he said.
The trial involves the drug solanezumab by Eli Lilly & Co., one of several drugs aimed at beta amyloid, the pieces of protein that clump together and destroy nerve cells in the brain in Alzheimer’s disease.
Earlier trials of solanezumab as a treatment showed little or no benefit for those who already had advanced Alzheimer’s. But it appeared to show promise for those in the earliest stages. That led to the A4 trial, co-sponsored by the company and the National Institute on Aging, as well as private philanthropies.
The A4 trial started in spring of 2014. The goal was to have 1,000 active participants by this month, so that there would be three-year results by December 2018.
But as of this month, fewer than 400 people have been “randomized” to receive either the drug or placebo, trial coordinators said.
“We really need people to participate because this is truly the first step to a cure,” said Dr. Amanda Smith, medical director for an A4 research site in Tampa at the University of South Florida.
Her team at the USF Health Byrd Alzheimer’s Institute had only two A4 patients receiving treatments as of early December after screening more than 40. Byrd staff members have been scrambling to find volunteers -- particularly from minority populations, which tend to be under-represented in clinical trials.
If the drug works, “this could be the last generation of people with dementia due to Alzheimer’s disease, and that’s a really exciting thing,” Smith said. “But we need the people to come in and participate in order to show that.”
Harvard neurologist Reisa Sperling, principal investigator, says it took longer than expected to get some sites ready and certified for the trial because of the expertise and equipment required. She said sites need to have PET (positron emission tomography), MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) and specialized software.
When the trial was launched in spring 2014, publicity piqued interest, especially among those who have a family history of Alzheimer’s disease. But some sites weren’t ready to begin screening at the time, Sperling said.
“Now I think most sites have caught up,” she said. “I am hopeful that we can finish up recruitment by this time next year.”
According to the A4 website (A4Study.org), the trial has 60 sites in the United States, Canada and Australia. Florida, which Sperling said is an important region for recruitment, has six sites:
· Tampa, USF Health Byrd Alzheimer Institute
· Miami Beach, Wien Center for Clinical Research
· West Palm Beach, Premiere Research Institute
· Orlando, Compass Research
· Leesburg, Compass Research North
· Jacksonville, Mayo Clinic
The Mayo Clinic had nine patients receiving either treatment or placebo as of early December, said trial coordinator Dana Haley.
“We had been collecting names of interested participants since we first heard about the study in late 2013, so we had a large pool to recruit from,” Haley said.
Volunteers for A4 who meet the entry criteria on age and other matters go through two levels of screening. The first level, as the Byrd Institute in Tampa conducts it, is an in-person conversation with a psychologist trained to use questions to elicit the level of functional memory.
Those who score in the normal range move on to a PET scan of their brain, which shows any abnormal protein deposits and other problems in vivid color. Those who have a positive screen for amyloid plaque are asked to join the A4 trial.
'This could be the last generation of people with dementia due to Alzheimer's disease, and that's a really exciting thing. But we need the people to come in and participate in order to show that.' - Dr. Amanda Smith, USF Health Byrd Alzheimer's Institute
If they agree, they then begin the monthly IV treatments, receiving either the saline solution or the drug, solanezumab. The IV infusion takes about half an hour once a month.
It doesn’t hurt, says Ed Hancock, one of the participants in the A4 trial at the Byrd Institute. He lives in Ocala but drives to Tampa for the treatments because he likes the team, including trial coordinator Kelly Rodrigo and nurse Beth Major.
“Beth is a pro,” Hancock said during a recent treatment. “It doesn’t hurt going in, doesn’t hurt coming out, and we have a lot of fun in between.”
As in other randomized, double-blind trials, neither the patients nor the staff know whether they’re receiving the experimental drug or the placebo, a saline solution.
If the drug works as intended, it will clear protein clumps called amyloid plaques out of the brain before they cause permanent damage. Tau, another protein thought by some to be the main culprit in Alzheimer’s disease, would be removed, as well.
In August 2104, when the USF team told Hancock that his PET scan was positive for amyloid plaque, he wasn’t surprised, he said. Both his parents died of Alzheimer’s, and his sister was diagnosed around 2007, he said.
“I try to stay pragmatic about it because the more you look for it, the more you’re going to see it, and the more worried about it you get, the bigger deal it becomes,” Hancock said.
Hancock, 66, serves as a director on the board of the Central-North Florida chapter of the Alzheimer’s Association. His educational and fundraising work is extensive, and he is still able to make all the required travel arrangements himself, said his wife Diana.
She said she doesn’t know whether that is a sign that he is getting solanezumab and it’s working, or whether he is getting the placebo and his brain is not yet damaged enough to cause symptoms.
Dr. Smith at the Byrd Institute says it is hard to know in such cases. “The thing is, we know that plaque starts to build up 10 to 15 years before people ever have the symptoms of forgetfulness,” she said.
A4 researchers had been warned that it might take 10 screenings to find one positive scan, but the rate of negatives at Byrd has been even higher than that. Of the first 43 people who have undergone screening in Tampa, just two qualified to undergo treatment.
Dr. Smith said even though the delay is frustrating, she’s happy for the many people who have undergone the PET scan and found out they are negative for amyloid.
“There are people who wake up worried every day (that they have Alzheimer’s disease in their future) and then have this PET scan and find out they don’t, and they are almost not sure what to do with themselves because they were so sure that they did,” she said.
Some who should be getting tested shy away. Participant Hancock, who has tried to recruit people for the A4 trial, says they claim to be too busy. He thinks they’re in denial.
“They’re not really concerned enough yet,” he said. “But they will be.”
One benefit of volunteering for clinical trials is that the medical care is free, and often it’s at a sophisticated research center. A particular advantage of this A4 trial is that people who pass the first level of screening get a free PET scan. Otherwise, an asymptomatic patient would have to pay $4,000 out-of-pocket.
Even if the news from the scan isn’t good, it is worthwhile finding out early, said Gloria Smith, president of the Florida Gulf Coast Chapter of the Alzheimer’s Association. (She is no relation to Dr. Amanda Smith.)
“There's a lot you can do,” Gloria Smith said. “You want to make decisions about your own life. You don't want your family to make those decisions for you.”
Finding a way to prevent Alzheimer’s would be of enormous benefit in Florida, she said. With the bulk of the Baby Boom still to hit age 65, she says, close to 500,000 Floridians already are living with Alzheimer's.
“The numbers are unbelievable,” she said. “And those aren't snowbirds I'm talking about. These are full-time residents.”
People interested in learning more about the Florida A4 trials can contact:
· Jacksonville, Mayo Clinic: Dana Haley - (904) 953-9680
· Tampa, USF Health Byrd Alzheimer Institute: Kelly Rodrigo - (813) 974-4904
· Orlando, Compass Research: Heather King - (407) 210-9838
· Leesburg, Compass Research North: (352) 314-0801
· Miami Beach, Wien Center for Clinical Research: Maria Greig-Custo - (305) 674-2121 Ext. 54480
· West Palm Beach, Premiere Research Institute: Linda Ormejuste - (561) 845-0500 Ext. 124