WLRN has partnered with PolitiFact to fact-check Florida politicians. The Pulitzer Prize-winning team seeks to present the true facts, unaffected by agenda or biases.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis said parents who seek gender-affirming care for their children subject those children to abuse — so much so that other nations have sought to ban it.
During the fourth Republican presidential primary debate Dec. 6 in Tuscaloosa, Alabama, DeSantis cited Sweden as an example.
"As a parent, you do not have the right to abuse your kids," DeSantis said. "This is cutting off their genitals, this is mutilating these minors, these are irreversible procedures. And this is something that other countries in Europe like Sweden, once they started doing it, they saw it did incalculable damage. They've shut it down."
It is hard for minors to get gender-affirming surgical care in Sweden. But much of that stems from a 1970s law that is unrelated to DeSantis’ point.
In 2022, health officials updated guidance for people younger than 18, advising chest surgery only in "exceptional cases." However, the new guidance is a recommendation — and is not comparable to the legal bans in some U.S. states.
What is gender-affirming care? Where does surgery fit in?
Gender-affirming care is an individualized approach to health care that supports transgender and nonbinary people’s gender identity and it can go beyond medical interventions. For the small population of youth diagnosed with gender dysphoria, this mainly involves support through social transition, puberty blockers and hormones as they become adolescents.
The gender-affirming surgery DeSantis cited is rarely performed on minors, said Dr. Marci Bowers, a gynecological surgeon and president of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health. Surgeries on minors happen "only under the most severe conditions of gender dysphoria," she said.
Gender dysphoria is the experience of distress that results when people’s sex assigned at birth does not match their gender identity.
"Top surgeries," or mastectomies, are more common than surgeries that alter genitalia.
In Europe more broadly, gender-affirming care availability is more often dictated by health policy or guidelines, not legal prohibitions.
U.S. lawmakers have taken a different approach, with states in some cases banning certain procedures. DeSantis signed a law in May that banned all gender-affirming medical care —– including puberty blockers, hormones and surgery.
Sweden has long restricted genital surgery
A 1975 Swedish law, which ended a decadeslong eugenics and forced-sterilization program, says that people younger than 18 cannot have genital surgeries. But the law doesn’t explicitly ban transgender care.
People seeking genital surgery must apply and be approved by the Legal Council at the Swedish Board of Health and Welfare. People younger than 23 seeking this surgery need "special circumstances" to get their applications approved, according to the Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer and Intersex Rights, also known as RFSL.
Sweden’s guidance on ‘top’ surgery and puberty blockers
In national guidelines updated in 2022, Swedish health officials cautioned that "the risks of puberty blockers and gender-affirming treatment are likely to outweigh the expected benefits." The guidelines recommended limiting use of puberty blockers, hormones and mastectomies to "exceptional cases."
"The guidelines are recommendations, and it's up to the physicians to interpret them and make a judgement in each specific case," said Jêran Rostam, an expert in trangender issues at RFSL.
The guidelines don’t "ban" top surgeries, but do signal shrinking access to the procedure.
Our ruling
Speaking about gender-affirming surgical care for minors, DeSantis said Sweden "shut it down."
A 1970s law on sterilization requires people in Sweden to be 18 or older to qualify for genital surgeries. The law does not explicitly ban transgender care. Citing potential risks, Swedish health officials in 2022 advised that mastectomies for minors be reserved for "exceptional cases." But it is not a legal prohibition.
The statement is partially accurate but leaves out important information. We rate it Half True.
Editor’s Note: Google Translate was used throughout the research of this story to translate websites and documents into English. We corroborated our understanding of translated documents with expert sources.
Sources
- Email interview with Jêran Rostam, expert on transgender issues at the The Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer and Intersex Rights or RFSL, Aug. 31, 2023
- Email interview with Deekshitha Ganesan, Policy Officer at TGEU (Transgender Europe), Aug. 31, 2023
- Interview with Marci Bowers, Gynecological surgeon and President of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, Oct. 12, 2023
- PolitiFact, "Gender-affirming surgery is not banned for minors in Europe, but is mostly inaccessible," Sept. 6, 2023
- PolitiFact, "Is all gender-affirming care for children ‘experimental’? Experts say no," Jan. 17, 2023
- PolitiFact, "Transition-related surgery limited to teens, not 'young kids.' Even then, it's rare," Aug. 10, 2022
- PolitiFact, "Fact-checking 3 claims in Tucker Carlson’s show on trans health care," Nov. 15, 2023
- PolitiFact, "Pence's point on gender-affirming care for minors ignores parental consent rules for tattoos," June 14, 2023
- PolitiFact, "How many trans people are there in the U.S., and why do we overestimate it?," July 13, 2023
- Reuters, "DeSantis signs Florida ban on transgender treatment for minors," May 18, 2023
- U.S. News and World Report, "States That Have Restricted Gender-Affirming Care for Trans Youth in 2023," Sept. 27, 2023
- Sveriges Riksdag, "Sterilization Act (1975:580)" (translated from Swedish), June 12, 1975
- Indiana International & Comparative Law Review, "Shared History of Shame: Sweden's Four-Decade Policy of Forced Sterilization and the Eugenics Movement in the United States," 1998
- The Washington Post, "Sweden Sterilized Thousands of 'Useless' Citizens For Decades," Aug. 29, 1997
- The Swedish National Board of Health and Welfare, "Care of children and adolescents with gender dysphoria," 2022
- The Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer and Intersex Rights, "Questions and answers about care for youth with gender dysphoria," July 4, 2023
- The Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer and Intersex Rights, "Why Do We Need a New Gender Recognition Act?," Jan. 27, 2022
- Sveriges Riksdag, "Act (1972:119) on determination of gender in certain cases" (translated from Swedish), 1972
- The Atlantic, "A Teen Gender-Care Debate Is Spreading Across Europe," April 28, 2023
- PolitiFact, "Puberty blockers: The facts and the myths," Aug. 28, 2023
- Annals of Plastic Surgery, "Gender-Affirming Mastectomy Trends and Surgical Outcomes in Adolescents," May 2022
- Politico, "The real story on Europe’s transgender debate," Oct. 8, 2023
Copyright 2023 WLRN 91.3 FM. To see more, visit WLRN 91.3 FM.
