Patients, Health Insurers Challenge Iowa's Effort To Privatize Medicaid

Oct 7, 2017
Originally published on October 17, 2017 5:01 pm

Iowa is one of 38 states that radically changed the way it runs Medicaid over the past few years. The state moved about 600,000 people on the government-run health program into care that is managed by for-profit insurance companies.

The idea is that the private companies would save the state money, but it has been a rocky transition in Iowa, especially for people like Neal Siegel.

Siegel is one of six disabled Iowans suing the state, alleging that Medicaid managed care, as it is known, deprives thousands of Iowans with disabilities the right to live safely in their homes.

Medicaid serves people with disabilities, low-income people and people in nursing homes. A combination of federal and state funds pays for the program. It covers 74 million people across the country these days, about half of whom are in Medicaid managed care.

Siegel, a former financial consultant, was in a hit-and-run bicycle crash four years ago that left him with a severe brain injury. He uses a wheelchair and can barely speak.

"I would probably put Neal at about 98 percent cognitive of what's going on around him, but unfortunately not able to articulate it," says Siegel's girlfriend, Beth Wargo. "So it's being trapped inside your own body."

After the accident, Siegel qualified for Medicaid. He lived in a rehabilitation center for a while, and the lawsuit, filed in U.S. district court in June, says he was the victim of abuse and neglect while living there.

Eventually, he moved home with Wargo, where he is reliant on caregivers to assist him with all activities of daily life.

Then last year, Wargo says, they got a letter in the mail from AmeriHealth Caritas, the company that manages his care. Siegel's budget for home help had been slashed by 50 percent, Wargo says. Siegel's face lights up as Wargo talks about the lawsuit, and he manages to say, "Oh yeah," when she mentions how happy they were that they could be part of it.

Cyndy Miller is the legal director with Disability Rights Iowa, the advocacy group that spearheaded the lawsuit.

"The system is too stressed right now with the way it's being managed, and it's not healthy for individuals with chronic or serious disabilities," says Miller.

According to the lawsuit, the company claimed that spending on Siegel's case was cut because it had exceeded a limit set in state policy. A spokesman for AmeriHealth Caritas said the company could not comment on ongoing litigation. The state has asked for the lawsuit to be dropped.

In addition to the suit, complaints about Medicaid from hospitals, doctors and patients have spiked in Iowa.

Iowa Department of Human Services Director Jerry Foxhoven defends moving the entire Medicaid population to managed care. He says more taxpayer dollars will be saved under private management.

But he says his agency is willing to make changes, especially for people like Neal, who have serious disabilities.

"Everything's always on the table. We're always looking at everything to say how do we best serve the people we're trying to serve and be the best stewards of taxpayer dollars," Foxhoven says.

For their part, the three companies with contracts in Iowa say in statements that the first 18 months have been successful. But they also have said to state officials that reimbursement rates were based on deeply flawed cost estimates provided to them before the project began.

They are now negotiating to get millions of dollars more in state funding.

So where is the savings? So far, no state has actually done a comprehensive review of whether private companies actually save Medicaid dollars, says Kelly Whitener, an associate professor with Georgetown University who studies managed care.

"You'd really need to be able to see are you saving money overall or not, and if you are spending less money, are you suppressing services that are needed? Or are you really finding efficiencies and only delivering care that families really need?" says Whitener.

For the moment, those questions don't have definitive answers.

Meanwhile, Iowa has to balance its books. Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds had to tap more than $260 million of the state's reserve fund this year, and officials expect next year's budget will be even tougher to negotiate. Medicaid funding will likely be a large part of the discussion.

This story is part of a reporting partnership with NPR, local member stations and Kaiser Health News.

Copyright 2017 Iowa Public Radio. To see more, visit Iowa Public Radio.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

Medicaid covers about 1 in 5 Americans. And more states are handing over the management of Medicaid to private insurance companies. Iowa did that last year. As Iowa Public Radio's Clay Masters reports, the transition has been rocky.

CLAY MASTERS, BYLINE: In Iowa, about a quarter of the state's population is on Medicaid. And last year, the state changed health care for all of those people - children, the poor, disabled and many elderly who need long-term care. Now all that care is managed by for-profit companies.

JERRY FOXHOVEN: I'm not so sure it was a bad decision to do everybody at once.

MASTERS: That's Jerry Foxhoven. He's the director of Iowa's Department of Human Services. The transition has not exactly been smooth. Complaints from both hospitals and patients have spiked, and six disabled Iowans have sued the state. Cyndy Miller is the legal director with Disability Rights IOWA, the advocacy group that organized the lawsuit.

CYNDY MILLER: The system is too stressed right now with the way it's being managed, and it's not healthy for individuals with chronic or serious disabilities.

MASTERS: The lawsuit alleges the privately run program is depriving thousands of Iowans with disabilities the right to live safely in their homes. One of the plaintiffs is Neal Siegel. Four years ago, the former financial consultant was in a hit-and-run bicycle crash leaving him with a severe brain injury. He lives with his girlfriend, Beth Wargo.

BETH WARGO: I would probably put Neal at about 98 percent cognitive of what's going on around him but unfortunately not able to articulate it out. So it's being trapped inside your own body.

MASTERS: After the accident, he got Medicaid. He lived in a rehabilitation center for a while. And the lawsuit says he was the victim of abuse and neglect while living there. Eventually he moved home. He's totally reliant on caregivers to assist him with all activities of daily life. Then last year, Wargo says they got a letter in the mail from AmeriHealth Caritas, the company that manages his care.

WARGO: Stating that Neal's budget has been slashed over 50 percent.

MASTERS: The lawsuit says the company claimed that was because their spending had exceeded a limit set in state policy. NPR contacted the company, and a spokesperson said he could not comment on ongoing litigation. When Wargo brings up the lawsuit, Neal lights up.

WARGO: They took it obviously, you can imagine. And that's where I met...

NEAL SIEGEL: (Groaning).

WARGO: Yeah. What do you say - oh, yeah.

SIEGEL: Oh, yeah.

WARGO: (Laughter).

MASTERS: The state has asked to drop the lawsuit. DHS Director Jerry Foxhoven says his agency is willing to make changes, especially for people like Neal with serious disabilities.

FOXHOVEN: Everything's always on the table because we're always looking at everything to say, how do we best serve the people that we're trying to serve and still be good stewards of the taxpayers' dollars?

MASTERS: Meanwhile, the three companies say in statements the first 18 months have been successful. But the companies have also said to state officials reimbursement rates were based on deeply flawed cost estimates provided to them before the project began. They are now negotiating to get millions of dollars more in state funding. Foxhoven says the system is better at saving money under private management. But so far, no state has actually done a comprehensive review of whether private companies do save Medicaid dollars, says Kelly Whitener with Georgetown University.

KELLY WHITENER: You'd really need to be able to see, are you saving money overall or not? And if you are spending less money, are you suppressing services that are needed, or are you really finding efficiencies and only delivering care that families really need?

MASTERS: Meanwhile, Iowa has to balance its books. Republican Governor Kim Reynolds had to tap more than $260 million in its reserve funds this year, and officials expect next year's budget will be even tougher. And Medicaid funding will likely be a large part of the discussion. For NPR News, I'm Clay Masters in Des Moines.

KELLY MCEVERS, HOST:

This story is part of a partnership with NPR, Iowa Public Radio and Kaiser Health News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.