Male OB-GYNs Are Rare, But Is That A Problem?

Apr 12, 2018
Originally published on May 3, 2018 8:28 am

As she leaves a 12-hour-day on the labor and delivery shift, Dr. Katie Merriam turns off her pager.

"I don't know what I'd do without it, you know? It's another limb. I always know where it is," she says, laughing.

The third-year resident in obstetrics and gynecology at the Carolinas Medical Center hospital in Charlotte, N.C., works in a medical specialty dominated by women, treating women. Merriam says she feels a special connection to her patients.

"You just, you can feel what they feel and understand why they feel certain ways. I do feel a special bond," she says.

Nationally, 82 percent of doctors matching into OB-GYN residency programs are women. Many OB-GYN patients say they prefer female doctors. Merriam's residency class is a bit of an anomaly — half of its members are men. Though it's nice to work with so many women, Merriam says, she and some of her female colleagues also like the perspective that men bring to the work environment.

"No one could really pinpoint about what balance they bring, but there's something nice about having them," she says.

It's important to have men in the field, she says, if only to continue to give patients options in their choice of providers. But most of her friends and other women she talks to, she says, want female doctors.

Blake Butterworth, a fourth-year obstetrics and gynecology resident at the Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston, says he doesn't take it personally when he hears that sort of thing from a patient.

"I don't get discouraged; I don't get offended," Butterworth says. "I gladly hand that patient off."

He's one of only two male residents in the program of 24 at MUSC and says he finds it rewarding when he can win a new patient's confidence.

"I have patients that clearly express disdain to have to see a guy," he says. "Then I develop rapport with her. And she says, 'I expected you to be X-Y-Z, and you were better than that.' "

Butterworth says he chose obstetrics and gynecology because it lets him develop long-term relationships with patients — providing routine OB-GYN care and more complicated surgeries if need be.

"Once you really get into it, and get involved in it, I don't think that bias [that the field is best left to women] holds true," he says.

Butterworth believes it is incumbent on male OB-GYNs to talk to male medical students about the benefits of having men in the field. Students need to know it's OK to have an interest in the field, he says, and that they will find work.

In fact, says Dr. Ashlyn Savage, an associate professor of obstetrics and gynecology at MUSC, it may be the opposite.

"In an effort to really diversify the applicant pool, we will apply in some cases different screening standards to decide who we are going to interview," Savage says. "For example, we might consider an applicant with a slightly lower board score — just to enhance how many men we are interviewing and considering."

It has been a challenge to find male OB-GYNs for the program, she says. The gender that at one time dominated the field is now at some schools considered a diversity hire. But Savage questions whether balancing the number of men and women in the specialty is as important as racial or ethnic diversity.

"The interesting thing to me is the primary motivation to [seek a diverse candidate pool] is so that patients have the opportunity to seek out physicians who might ... feel like themselves," she says. "In this particular case ... all of the patients for OB-GYNs are women."

Among practicing OB-GYNs in the U.S., a little fewer than half are men, according to the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. But ACOG predicts that 10 years from now, two-thirds of the doctors in that specialty will be female.

Still, male doctors hold a lot of the key positions in OB-GYN professional organizations.

"Leadership tends to be held by people who are older," Savage says. "And we are still in a scenario where [more of] our older faculty tend to be men."

A study published last fall found that women are underrepresented in leadership roles in medical school departments of obstetrics and gynecology all around the country. That ratio was most lopsided in men's favor in the South.

It's perhaps only a matter of time before that, too, changes. Savage says she just learned that her program's incoming class of OB-GYN residents next year will be all female.

This story is part of NPR's reporting partnership with WFAE and Kaiser Health News.

Copyright 2018 WFAE. To see more, visit WFAE.

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

Obstetrics and gynecology were fields that were once dominated by male doctors. Today, most graduating OB-GYNs are women. In fact, so few men are going into these fields, there's a discussion about whether more should be done to balance it all out. From member station WFAE in Charlotte, Alex Olgin reports.

ALEX OLGIN, BYLINE: As she leaves a 12-hour day on the labor and delivery shift, Dr. Katie Merriam turns off her pager.

KATIE MERRIAM: I don't know what I would do without it. You know? It's like another limb. I always know where it is, and (laughter).

OLGIN: The third-year resident in obstetrics and gynecology at the Carolinas Medical Center Hospital in Charlotte is in a field all about women, dominated by women. Merriam says she feels a special connection to her patients.

MERRIAM: You can feel what they feel, and you can understand why they feel certain ways. And, yeah, I do feel like there's a special bond.

OLGIN: Nationally, 82 percent of doctors matching into OB-GYN residency programs are women. Her residency class is a bit of an anomaly because it's half men. Merriam thinks it's important to have men in the field to continue to give patients options, especially because there's a shortage of OB-GYNs in a lot of places. But she says most of her friends want female docs. That was true of a number of women I spoke with.

LATASIA BLACK: I'd prefer a female than a male.

QUIONDA DUKE: I prefer to have a female, honestly.

JESSICA COOPER: I would prefer a female.

OLGIN: That was Latasia Black (ph), Quionda Duke (ph) and Jessica Cooper (ph).

BLAKE BUTTERWORTH: I don't get discouraged. I don't get offended. You know, I gladly hand that patient off.

OLGIN: Blake Butterworth, a fourth-year obstetrics and gynecology resident at the Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston, says patients request female doctors less often than he expected. He's one of only two male residents in the MUSC program of 24.

BUTTERWORTH: What I find rewarding is when sometimes you'll have those patients that they're like, I guess I have to see a guy, and that's OK. Whatever. Send him in. And then you end up, like, developing a rapport with her. And she says at the end, like, well, I expected you to be X, Y, Z, and you were so much better than that.

OLGIN: He went into the field because doctors often establish long-term relationships with patients. He says obstetrics and gynecology wasn't on his radar before his rotation in medical school, partly because of the stereotype that it's a female field.

BUTTERWORTH: As males, we don't really understand the full variety and breadth of the specialty. But I think once you really get into it and get involved with it, I don't think that bias holds true.

OLGIN: Butterworth believes it's incumbent on male OB-GYNs to talk to male medical students about the field as well as dispel myths he was told like it'll be hard to find work as a man. In fact, says Dr. Ashlyn Savage, with MUSC, it may be the opposite. She says it's been a challenge to find male doctors.

ASHLYN SAVAGE: We might consider an applicant with a slightly lower board score just to enhance how many men we're interviewing and considering.

OLGIN: The sex that at one time dominated the field is now being considered by some schools as a diversity hire. But Savage questions how important it is to bring in men compared to searching for a doctor pool with more racial or ethnic diversity.

SAVAGE: The primary motivation to do so is so that patients will have the opportunity to seek out physicians who might for them feel like themselves. In this particular case, by nature, all of patients for OB-GYNs are women.

OLGIN: Or those who are transgender with female anatomy. The field of practicing OB-GYNs is now over half women. More younger doctors are women, while more older doctors tend to be men. In addition, she says...

SAVAGE: Leadership tends to be held by those who are older, and we're still in a scenario where our older faculty tend to be more men.

OLGIN: A 2017 study found women are underrepresented in department leadership roles around the country. The ratio was the worst in the South. But Savage just found out the incoming residents for next year at USC will be all female. For NPR News, I'm Alex Olgin.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

MARTIN: This story's part of a reporting partnership with NPR, WFAE and Kaiser Health News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.